The Original London Cast Recording. Recording 1972 Jesus of Nazareth - Paul Nicholas, Judas Iscariot - Stephen Tate, Mary Magdalene - Dana Gillespie, Pontius Pilate - John Parker, King Herod - Paul Jabara, Caiaphas - George Harris, Annas - Jimmy Cassidy, Simon Zealotes - Derek James, Peter - Richard Barnes, Priest 1 - Mark Rusel, Priest 2 - John Newton, Priest 3 - David Charkham.