Jesus Christ Superstar OST, soundtrack. 1973. Jesus of Nazareth - Ted Neeley, Judas Iscariot - Carl Anderson, Mary Magdalene - Yvonne Elliman, Pontius Pilate - Barry Dennen, King Herod - Josh Mostel, Caiaphas - Bob Bingham, Annas - Kurt Yaghjian, Simon Zealotes - Larry T. Marshall.