Jesus Christ Superstar. New Zealand Cast Recording Highlights. Recording 1994 Jesus of Nazareth - Darryl Lovegrove, Judas Iscariot - Jay Laga'aia, Mary Magdalene - Margaret Urlich, Pontius Pilate - George Henare, King Herod - Mark Hadlow, Caiaphas - Frankie Stevens, Simon Zealotes - Jonathan Brooke, Peter - Tim Beveridge.